Who We Are

Schatz Insurance logo

Independent Insurance Agency

At Schatz Insurance Agency, we believe that service is paramount. While you can buy insurance from any agency or company, it's the quality of service you receive when you need us that truly sets us apart. Founded in 1977 by Otis Schatz, Jay Cox took over the company in 1999 and relocated it to its current location in Huntingburg, IN in 2004.

We prioritize building lasting relationships with our clients by taking the time to get to know our clients and their businesses, becoming partners in their success rather than just insurance agents.

At Schatz Insurance Agency, you're more than just a policyholder – you're part of our extended family.

Meet the Team

Jay Cox

Owner / Acct Executive

Jay Cox


CSR / Office Manager

Teresa Underhill



Karen Escobar